In Association with Amazon.com

BUYING/SELLING HUMAN ORGANS

What's the going price for a live human kidney in Manila or a section of living human liver in Bombay?  This is Dr. Steven Andrew Davis, Speaking of Health.  The success for recipients of transplanted organs has spawned a worldwide shortage of potential donors and a black market for human organs.  According to a report in The New England Journal of Medicine, "in 2000, nearly 5000 patients were removed from the list (of those waiting for organs) because of death.  Now, if you or a family member were faced with imminent death unless an organ could be found, would you consider buying an organ from a healthy donor--even if it was illegal?

In the US, the National Organ Transplant Act prohibits the assignment of monetary value to an organ for transplantation, thus,  in theory, preventing commerce in human organs.  Health officials encourage goodwill as incentive to donate organs.  And Yet, according to this report, the current price for a woman's kidney in Bombay is $1,000 and in urban Latin America a kidney can fetch more than $10,000.  In schemes to obtain a kidney overseas and have it transplanted in the US several hundred thousand dollars can change hands, unrelated to the surgery itself.

Several proposals have been before Congress on this complex medical, social and ethical issue.  Where will it lead as thousands benefit from organ transplantation and others wait for organs to arrive before it's too late.  For a copy of this script and the journal reference, access our web site--speakingofhealth.com.  Speaking of Health, I'm Dr. Steven Andrew Davis, for CBS News.

N Engl J Med, Vol. 346, No. 25 June 20, 2002. Pgs. 2002-2005

E-Mail drdavis@davishealth.com


Dr. Steve Davis
7810 Louis Pasteur #200
San Antonio, Texas 78229
210/614-3355